Citation
von Ruden, Galilea Bascara (2018) Why the Turing Test Revised is Still the Turing Test. Other, California Institute of Technology. doi:10.7907/9KP0-TQ82. https://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechTHESIS:02052019-142127450
Abstract
Can machines think? So Alan Turing begins his paper "Computing Machinery and Intelligence", discussing how one might assess whether an electronic computer can truly "think" (Turing, 1950, p. 29). It is here that Turing explains his famous Turing Test: can a computer win in an "imitation game" with a human? That is, can an electronic computer provide written answers to an interrogator which would fool the interrogator into believing that device is human? To answer yes, Turing argues, is to acknowledge the reality of a thinking machine (Turing, 1950, p. 30). Since 1950, technology has advanced impressively. There has been a computer that “passed” the Turing Test, fooling testers with a clever ability to redirect conversation when questions became too challenging (Marcus, 2014). Yet this strategy feels more like a cheap trick than the mark of an authentic thinker, casting doubt on the test’s validity. What could be a more reliable test for machine understanding? I argue for two simple additions to the Turing Test that would eliminate loopholes but leave the spirit of the test unchanged. That Turing's original imagination of the Turing Test involved a game of deception is distracting to its fundamental principle: we will say a machine “thinks” when its logical outputs are in no way noticeably inferior to that of a human.
Item Type: | Thesis (Other) |
---|---|
Subject Keywords: | Alexander P. and Adelaide F. Hixon Prize for Writing ; Alexander P. and Adelaide F. Hixon Prize for Writing in Freshman Humanities ; Hixon Writing Center |
Degree Grantor: | California Institute of Technology |
Division: | Humanities and Social Sciences |
Major Option: | Humanities |
Awards: | Alexander P. and Adelaide F. Hixon Prize for Writing, 2018. |
Thesis Availability: | Restricted to Caltech community only |
Research Advisor(s): |
|
Group: | Alexander P. and Adelaide F. Hixon Prize for Writing, Alexander P. and Adelaide F. Hixon Prize for Writing in Freshman Humanities, Hixon Writing Center |
Thesis Committee: |
|
Defense Date: | 2018 |
Record Number: | CaltechTHESIS:02052019-142127450 |
Persistent URL: | https://resolver.caltech.edu/CaltechTHESIS:02052019-142127450 |
DOI: | 10.7907/9KP0-TQ82 |
Default Usage Policy: | No commercial reproduction, distribution, display or performance rights in this work are provided. |
ID Code: | 11384 |
Collection: | CaltechTHESIS |
Deposited By: | Leslie Rico |
Deposited On: | 20 Feb 2019 23:53 |
Last Modified: | 03 Aug 2022 23:19 |
Thesis Files
PDF
- Accepted Version
Restricted to Caltech community only See Usage Policy. 236kB |
Repository Staff Only: item control page